The R&B music community experienced a significant loss on June 26th with the passing of Walter Scott, a member of The Whispers. Reflecting on how to pay tribute to his legacy, I considered various options. Ultimately, I found inspiration last Sunday in the song “A Song For Donny,” which proved to be an appropriate selection for this week’s edition of Slow Jam Saturday.
The lead single from their self-titled sixth album, “A Song For Donny,” has the instrumental foundation of Hathaway’s timeless “This Christmas,” and the lyrics (by Carrie Lucas) are a simple but effective substitution of mournful remembrance for yuletide jollity. The Whispers are famous for their wordless ad-libs and velvety smoothness, but in “A Song for Donny,” they pull back a bit. The gravity of the subject matter and the sincerity of their devotion force them to be a little more restrained, a little more sacred.
The first time you hear that opening riff, you’re already enveloped. “He sang a song as if he knew / the magic that he had inside,” they intone as one in lush four-part harmony, and right there, you feel it. You can almost see him up there on that church stage, those tenors’ smiles wide, the melody already lifting from their lips and into the choir loft and out of this world.
David Arnold’s arrangement is straightforward, which is precisely what makes it effective. It allows the song to shine and lets the vocals take center stage. The only embellishments needed are the shimmering harmonies, a solid bass line, and a groove that everyone knows by heart. You can almost visualize the flicker of candles in a chapel and hear the whispers as they continue to sing to us and Donny. Each verse feels like a prayer.
“A Song for Donny” is so effective because it knows when to be quiet. There’s no grandstanding. It’s a eulogy, not a showcase. It’s a prayer, not a testifier—a black-and-white photograph in a gold frame. There is silence in the room just before the preacher steps up to the pulpit. The proof that soul music is less about the music and more about the memories.
“A Song for Donny” isn’t just a tribute to an artist. It’s a testament to love. In four minutes and nineteen seconds, The Whispers crafted a musical benediction that endures almost half a century later.
If you’ve ever grieved for a departed artist or even a departed friend who left us far too soon, then “A Song for Donny” is a song for you.
Thank you for the memories, Mr. Scott
Final Grade: A
“A Song For Donny” is available on all streaming platforms.
This week’s Second Listen Sunday pick takes us back to 2006 to revisit “So Amazin’,” the third album from Christina Milian. Arriving in stores on April 19 of that year, the project was produced largely by Cool & Dre, sans one song, and saw the singer earn writing credits on nine of the album’s songs.
For this week’s Slow Jam Saturday, I want to showcase love for Rahsaan Patterson and his album track “Can We Wait a Minute” from his self-titled debut album, released in 1997.
For this week’s Second Listen Sunday, I wanted to take a trip back to 2000 and show some love to the R&B duo K-Ci & JoJo and their third album, “X,” which was released in stores on December 5, just in time for a holiday stocking stuffer. Arguably, the group suffered from the sophomore slump with their second album, as only two singles were successful.