Derrick Dunn

Derrick Dunn

Randall Park makes a charming directorial debut in Shortcomings

Comedian Randall Park adds another notch to his impressive resume with his directorial debut Shortcomings from Sony Pictures Classics. Adrian Tomine pens the film’s screenplay, which is an adaption of his graphic novel. The cast includes Justin H. Min, Sherry Cola, and Ally Maki, all of whom are Asian American.

 The film opens with a mock romantic comedy featuring actors Ronny Chieng and Stephanie Hsu. The audience eats the film up, but aspiring filmmaker Ben (Min) feels disgusted. Ben Tanaka, a Japanese American man residing in California, finds himself struggling with his cultural identity and personal relationships. From the moment Min appears, Min gives the character a convincing film snob vibe. This personality trait of Ben carries the mood of the film as Ben embarks on a journey filled with self-discovery, examining his insecurities and the limitations of his worldview.

One of the film’s greatest strengths lies in its ability to tackle sensitive subjects with nuance and thoughtfulness. It doesn’t shy away from addressing the complexities of racial and ethnic identity, exploring the challenges faced by individuals caught between different cultural worlds. For example, Ben thinks having a white girl on his arm will equal acceptance. Tavi Gevinson and Debby Ryan portray two of Ben’s attempts at romance with humorous results.

Shortcomings also delve into the intricacies of modern relationships, mainly focusing on the dynamics between Ben, his girlfriend Miko (Maki), and his best friend, Alice. The script explores jealousy, trust, and communication themes, shedding light on the flaws and vulnerabilities that can strain even the strongest bonds. The cast members’ performances are commendable, bringing emotional depth and authenticity to their characters’ struggles.

The film visually captures the essence of the graphic novel, utilizing a unique style that enhances the storytelling. The cinematography flawlessly brings to life the vibrant atmosphere of California while contrasting it with the character’s inner turmoil. However, Shortcomings isn’t a mainstream film. 

Its deliberately slow pace and introspective nature may deter viewers from seeking fast-paced, action-driven narratives. Additionally, some might find the narrative exploration of specific themes, such as racial identity, forced. Despite these minor drawbacks, Shortcomings remains a thought-provoking and emotionally resonant film that invites audiences to reflect on their experiences of identity, relationships, and personal growth. It successfully captures the essence of Adrian Tomine’s graphic novel, delivering a compelling and poignant narrative that will leave a lasting impact.

Shortcomings is a decent film that highlights the complexities of identity, cultural assimilation, and relationships. Its authentic performances, sensitive storytelling, and visual aesthetics offer a compelling and reflective cinematic experience that will resonate with audiences long after the credits roll.

 Final Grade: B+

Shortcomings is in theaters now.

Movie Clappers

More reviews to explorer


Aporia is a different time travel story

Jared Moshe explores the classic science fiction trope in his latest film, Aporia from Well Go USA. Since losing her husband Mal (Edi Gathegi) in a drunk-driving incident, Sophie (Judy Greer) has struggled to manage crippling grief, a full-time job, and the demands of parenting her devastated teenage daughter (Faithe Herman).

Mindless action fills King of Killers

Multi-faceted talent Kevin Grevioux brings his graphic novel King Of Killers to life in a same-titled film from Lionsgate. Following the murder of his wife, former Agency hitman Marcus Garan (Alain Moussi) is down his luck. While his mother-in-law and daughter try their best to support him, Marcus has seen better days. His former handler, Robert Xane (Stephen Doff), thinks Marcus should cool his jets when it comes to unraveling the mystery behind a tragic incident.

A Million Miles Away is a standard biopic saved by Michael Peña

Acclaimed director Alejandra Márquez Abella collaborates with Michael Peña for her latest film, A Million Miles Away, a biopic of Jose Hernandez, the first migrant farmworker to travel to space. Abella pens the film’s screenplay with Bettina Gilois, and Hernán Jiménez which adapts based on Hernández’s memoir, Reaching for the Stars: The Inspiring Story of a Migrant Farmworker Turned Astronaut.

Randall Park makes a charming directorial debut in Shortcomings

Randall Park makes a charming directorial debut in Shortcomings