Montana Story
Derrick Dunn

Derrick Dunn

Montana Story is textbook Sundance fare

Coming to grips with the past is the centerpiece of Bleecker Street’s family drama Montana Story. Writing and directing duo Scott McGehee and David Siegel collaborate again for the film, which I must warn viewers is a slow-moving drama.

The film tells the story of two estranged siblings Erin (Haley Lu Richardson) and Cal (Owen Teague), returning home to the sprawling ranch they once knew and loved, confronting a deep and bitter family legacy against a mythic American backdrop.

Montana Story introduces Cal first in a standard setup that screams favorite son. The family patriarch is bedridden in the living room and under the care of hospice nurse Ace (Gilbert Owuor) and a family friend Valentia (Kimberly Guerrero). Cal wants his father to pass away peacefully, take care of his dad’s creditors and move on with his life. Cal decides the best bet is to sell Mr. T, a twenty-five-year-old black stallion with arthritis, on advice from the bank.

Things twist when Erin shows back up after a septet stint living in upstate New York. For reasons easy to guess, Erin left Montana a while back after a harrowing incident with her father. Since Cal stood by helplessly, Erin washed her hands of any relationship with him. When Erin learns of Cal’s plans to sell Mr. T, she insists the horse come back to New York with her. Thus begins a road trip between the two and hopefully some much-needed healing.

As I alluded to earlier in my review, Montana Story is a slow-moving drama. The film is very dialogue-driven, with very few happy moments in the movie. The writers and directors avoid typical tropes of having Owen and Erin reconnected through road trip karaoke or giving each other dating advice. In addition, while the set up is there, the script never turns Ace (Gilbert Owuor) into a magical black man who can cure the characters’ problems.

In the lead roles of Erin & Cal, both Haley Lu Richardson and Owen Teague commit to their performances. Both actors give a performance that will lead to bigger and better things as the acting comes across natural. However, this is not the type of movie that screams mainstream despite the strong acting. Yes, the cinematography is gorgeous, and there are some great shots of The Treasure State. Still, like Nomadland, Montana Story is a movie with a niche audience who will love it. In contrast, others will question why the film was ever greenlit.

Final Grade: C

Montana Story is in theaters now

Movie Clappers

More to explorer

Thor: Love and Thunder

Thor: Love and Thunder is a safe cinematic lighting strike

Stylistic director Taika Waiti makes a return to the Marvel Cinematic with Thor: Love and Thunder from Walt Disney Pictures. The Asgardian’s fourth led film finds Thor (Chris Hemsworth) on a journey unlike anything he’s ever faced, a quest for inner peace. However, a galactic killer known as Gorr the God Butcher (Christian Bale), who seeks the extinction of the gods, interrupts his retirement.

Hot Seat

Hot Seat is a burnt out thriller

Director James Cullen Bressack continues to add to his filmography of low-rated B-Movies with his latest Hot Seat from Lionsgate. IT expert Friar (Kevin Dillon) finds a hair-trigger bomb strapped to his desk chair. An unseen hacker orders him to steal digital funds online–or have his daughter abducted.