My introduction to Edward Burns came in 1996 with “She’s the One”, a film I first watched as a 15-year-old who was crushing on Jennifer Aniston something serious. Over the years, Burns has carved out a lane telling stories about family, regret, romance, and people carrying emotional baggage they should have unpacked years ago. That is why “Finnegan’s Foursome” sounds like it should be right in his wheelhouse.
Burns directs and stars as Freddy Finnegan, one of two brothers traveling to Ireland after the death of their father, Jack Finnegan, a former PGA golfer and first-generation Irish immigrant. Freddy and his older brother, Teddy, played by Brian d’Arcy James, are tasked with honoring Jack’s final wish: continuing the family’s Finnegan Cup golf tradition while spreading his ashes in a few meaningful locations along the way. Joining them are Frankie and Marie, the next generation of Finnegans, who appear to love the game without carrying the same resentment that has long divided their fathers.
To the film’s credit, “Finnegan’s Foursome” looks beautiful. Ireland gives the movie a postcard-ready backdrop, and the golf courses are captured with enough care to make the family tradition feel visually appealing. The issue is that once the scenery settles in, the story does not always have enough weight behind it. What should be a touching journey about grief, brotherhood, and forgiveness too often feels like a long weekend golf trip stretched into a feature-length drama.
The film works best when it slows down and lets its cast find the emotional beats. Brian d’Arcy James is the standout as Teddy, bringing warmth, patience, and a steady presence to the role. He gives the story its clearest moral center, especially when encouraging Freddy to make peace with their father’s memory instead of holding on to old wounds. Erica Hernandez also makes a welcome impression as Marie, adding a fresh energy that helps balance out the heavier dose of male bonding.
Still, “Finnegan’s Foursome” has trouble keeping its emotional swing consistent. The golf banter, reaction shots, and repeated course sequences begin to wear down the film’s more sincere moments. By the time the story reaches for sentiment, some of its impact has already been dulled.
“Finnegan’s Foursome” is not without charm. It has a capable cast, gorgeous Irish scenery, and a heartfelt idea at its center. However, Edward Burns’ family golf drama ultimately reads better on paper than it plays on screen.
Grade: C+
